Skip to main content

Pirates’ Joey Bart decision could backfire after former catcher lands with division rival

Meanwhile, Pittsburgh still has a lot of the same questions behind the plate.
ByEmma Lingan
Pittsburgh Pirates v Arizona Diamondbacks
Pittsburgh Pirates v Arizona Diamondbacks | Norm Hall/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Pirates may have thought they had solved their catching logjam when they traded Joey Bart to the Atlanta Braves in June. Five months later, Bart is joining a division rival, and the Pirates' own catching situation is arguably more complicated than it was when they let him go.

According to FanSided's Robert Murray, Bart is signing with the Chicago Cubs, just three days after being designated for assignment by the Chicago White Sox. The move gives the former Pirates catcher another opportunity to revive his career while adding an uncomfortable wrinkle to Pittsburgh's offseason.

Bart spent parts of the 2024, 2025 and 2026 seasons in Pittsburgh before being traded to Atlanta in exchange for right-handed reliever Hunter Stratton on June 18. At the time, general manager Ben Cherington determined that the combination of Henry Davis and Endy Rodríguez gave the Pirates their best chance to succeed behind the plate.

That decision may have been defensible at the time. Whether it has aged particularly well is another question entirely.

Joey Bart's Cubs signing puts Pirates' uncertain catching plans back under scrutiny

When Cherington traded Bart, he expressed confidence that Davis and Rodríguez offered the ideal balance of offensive potential and defensive reliability. Rodríguez had begun showing encouraging signs at the plate, while Davis was considered the organization's superior defensive option.

Unfortunately, that plan didn't survive the season. Rodríguez underwent surgery to repair the labrum in his left hip in August, ending a promising campaign in which he slashed .267/.373/.467 across 45 games. His recovery timeline of seven to nine months to resume baseball activities creates significant uncertainty about his availability early in 2027.

Davis, meanwhile, continued struggling to establish himself offensively. The former No. 1 overall pick finished the season hitting just .164/.264/.295 with 10 home runs, raising increasingly difficult questions about whether his defensive contributions can compensate for his lack of production at the plate. Rafael Flores Jr. emerged as a legitimate alternative, slashing .275/.336/.508 in 40 games, but relying on another relatively inexperienced catcher comes with its own risks.

None of this necessarily means Pittsburgh made a mistake trading Bart. The former second overall pick struggled after leaving the Pirates, finishing 2026 with a .214/.305/.357 slash line, four home runs and 13 RBI across 44 games split between Pittsburgh, Atlanta and the White Sox. His brief stint with the White Sox was interrupted by a fractured left hand, and Chicago ultimately decided against keeping him on its 40-man roster.

Chicago has its own catching questions to answer, and Bart gives the organization another option without requiring a substantial investment. The Cubs clearly see enough potential to give him another opportunity, even after three organizations parted ways with him during the 2026 season.

For Pittsburgh, the bigger issue isn't necessarily the possibility of Bart finding success with a division rival. It's that the Pirates parted with him because they believed they had better answers internally, only to finish the season with many of the same questions.

If Bart rediscovers his offensive potential in Chicago, the optics will only get worse. But the Pirates don't need Bart to fail for their decision to look justified. They need Davis, Rodríguez and Flores to prove that Cherington was right to move on from him in the first place.

Add us as a preferred source on Google