Pirates’ new rumored competitor for Brandon Lowe adds uncomfortable déjà vu to free agency

The Pittsburgh Pirates have officially entered the portion of the offseason where retaining Brandon Lowe is starting to look a whole lot more complicated. And the latest team reportedly interested in their star second baseman might give longtime Pirates fans an unpleasant sense of déjà vu.

According to Shi Davidi and Ben Nicholson-Smith of Sportsnet, the Toronto Blue Jays have expressed preliminary interest in Lowe, who is coming off an outstanding first season in Pittsburgh. Discussions haven't progressed beyond the exploratory stage, but Toronto's emergence as a potential suitor is noteworthy for several reasons.

For starters, the Blue Jays have the financial resources to make a legitimate run at Lowe. They're also coming off a disastrous offensive season in which they finished last in MLB with 648 runs scored and 152 home runs. Adding a second baseman who just launched 35 homers while earning Gold Glove finalist recognition would address two significant needs.

But for Pirates fans who have been around long enough, there's another reason Toronto's reported interest should sound familiar.

The last time the Pirates extended a qualifying offer to a prominent position player, the Blue Jays signed him away. And Pittsburgh might be headed toward a frustrating repeat of history.

Blue Jays' Brandon Lowe interest brings Russell Martin's Pirates departure back into focus

Back in 2014, the Pirates extended a $15.3 million qualifying offer to catcher Russell Martin, hoping to retain one of the most important contributors to their recent resurgence.

Martin declined, as expected, and entered free agency looking for a multiyear contract. The Blue Jays ultimately swooped in with a five-year, $82 million offer that Pittsburgh wasn't prepared to match. The Pirates received draft compensation for losing Martin, eventually using the No. 32 overall pick in 2015 to select Ke'Bryan Hayes. We all know how that turned out.

Regardless of whether the pick ended up producing a valuable major league player in the end, it did nothing to immediately replace Martin's contributions behind the plate or his importance to a Pittsburgh team that was trying to capitalize on a competitive window.

Now, 12 years later, the Pirates are staring down a remarkably similar situation. Lowe received a one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer after hitting .260 with 35 home runs, 96 RBI and an .824 OPS in 2026. He also made significant defensive improvements at second base and helped Pittsburgh secure its first winning season since 2018.

Like Martin, Lowe is widely expected to reject the qualifying offer in pursuit of a more lucrative multiyear agreement. And like Martin, he could find that Toronto is willing to make the kind of financial commitment Pittsburgh has historically been reluctant to offer.

The possibility that Toronto could once again outbid Pittsburgh for one of its most valuable players feels like a particularly cruel irony — especially when the Pirates should be doing everything possible to build upon the progress they made in 2026.

Lowe was entering the final year of his contract when the Pirates acquired him last year, and his power-hitting ability made him an obvious candidate to test free agency if he performed well. Pittsburgh took that gamble, and the acquisition paid off tremendously. Now comes the part where the Pirates have to decide whether they're serious about keeping the player who helped make that gamble worthwhile.

Extending the qualifying offer was a necessary first step, but it was hardly an aggressive statement of intent. Pittsburgh is essentially protecting its right to receive draft compensation if Lowe signs elsewhere. That might be sound asset management, but it's not a substitute for building a competitive major league roster.

The Pirates finished 82-80 in 2026, finally snapping a seven-year streak of losing seasons, and Lowe was instrumental in that improvement. And while Pittsburgh established a franchise home run record, its offense still suffered from significant inconsistency, particularly during the second half of the season. Removing a 35-homer bat from that equation without securing a comparable replacement would be an enormous step backward.

Meanwhile, Toronto is coming off a 79-83 season and apparently recognizes that improving its offense will require meaningful investment.

None of this means Pittsburgh should offer Lowe a reckless contract simply to prevent him from signing elsewhere. But there's a difference between exercising financial discipline and allowing another team's willingness to spend to dictate the future of your roster. The Pirates learned that lesson the hard way when Martin left for Toronto in 2014, and they shouldn't need another reminder in 2026.

If the Blue Jays ultimately sign Lowe away from Pittsburgh, the Pirates won't be able to claim they didn't see it coming. They've watched this exact franchise deliver that disappointment before.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow