Pirates somehow turn Brandon Lowe’s historic season into another letdown

Brandon Lowe has given the Pittsburgh Pirates almost everything they could have asked for this season.

Thirty home runs. Legitimate middle-of-the-order production. Veteran credibility. One of the best power seasons Pittsburgh has seen in years.

And somehow, the Pirates are still positioned to turn all of it into another missed opportunity.

Lowe’s solo home run against the Brewers gave him 30 for the season, making him the first Pirates hitter to reach that mark since Josh Bell in 2019. It was also his 16th home run at PNC Park, making him only the eighth player to hit that many in a season since the ballpark opened.

Lowe's homer was Pittsburgh’s 171st of the year, tying the franchise record set in 1999. So the Pirates finally built an offense with real power and added the kind of proven veteran bat they have spent years lacking — and they're still going to miss the playoffs.

That's bad enough. What makes it worse is that Lowe probably won't even be here when the Pirates try again.

Lowe is headed toward free agency after producing exactly the kind of season that will make him more expensive. And with the Pirates, that tends to be where the story ends. Not because they literally cannot afford him, but because history suggests they will decide they can't.

Pirates’ Brandon Lowe problem exposes the same old ownership failure

Pittsburgh operates with payroll limitations largely of its own making. When a player like Lowe performs well enough to command a meaningful multiyear deal, the conversation immediately shifts toward whether he has “priced himself out” of Pittsburgh.

In reality, Lowe didn't price himself out. He earned his next contract, and the Pirates would be the ones choosing not to pay it.

This should have been the payoff. Lowe was the kind of acquisition fans have begged this organization to make for years: an established major-league hitter with real power who could deepen the lineup around a young core. He delivered, but the organization around him didn't deliver enough.

Now the most likely outcome is that Lowe leaves, takes his 30-homer bat somewhere willing to pay market value and forces the Pirates to spend the winter searching for another version of the player they already had.

The cycle is exhausting. Find a productive veteran. Watch him thrive. Explain why keeping him is too expensive. Start searching for a cheaper replacement.

Lowe could go down as one of the greatest one-and-dones in Pirates history and still have no postseason appearance to show for it. That should be viewed not as some bittersweet success story, but as a failure to capitalize.

Seasons like Lowe’s are supposed to help change the direction of a franchise. But with the Pirates, it looks increasingly likely to become another reminder of just how quickly a good thing can disappear once the bill comes due.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow