The Pittsburgh Pirates apparently see something in Akil Baddoo worth keeping around. The more interesting question is what that might mean for Esmerlyn Valdez.
In a somewhat surprising move ahead of Friday's non-tender deadline, the Pirates agreed to terms with Baddoo on a contract for the 2027 season. Pittsburgh also non-tendered right-handed pitcher Noah Murdock, who appeared in just three major league games in 2026.
Baddoo's retention is the more intriguing development, particularly considering he had been widely viewed as the Pirates' most obvious non-tender candidate after being claimed off waivers from the Milwaukee Brewers earlier this month.
The 28-year-old outfielder didn't appear in a major league game in 2026, though he hit .252/.342/.469 with 11 home runs in 64 games at Triple-A Nashville. MLB Trade Rumors projected him to earn $1.3 million through arbitration, hardly an exorbitant figure but still a notable commitment to a player without a clear spot on Pittsburgh's roster.
Baddoo's new deal is a split contract, meaning he'll earn different salaries depending on whether he's in the majors or minors. However, he's also out of minor league options, meaning the Pirates would have to expose him to waivers before assigning him to Triple-A.
In other words, this isn't quite the straightforward organizational depth move it might initially appear to be. And that raises an interesting possibility: Could Baddoo be an insurance policy for Valdez?
The Pirates have agreed to terms on a 2027 contract with Akil Baddoo. Noah Murdock has been non-tendered.
— Aiden Stepansky (@AidenStepansky) November 20, 2026
Murdock turned 28 in August and pitched in three games for the Pirates in 2026. Baddoo is a split contract, meaning he'd have to clear waivers to go to the minors.
Pirates may already be preparing for Esmerlyn Valdez's growing pains
Valdez was one of Pittsburgh's most exciting breakout players in 2026, hitting 17 home runs with an .855 OPS in just 72 games. His remarkable July, which included eight home runs and NL Rookie of the Month honors, offered a glimpse of his enormous offensive potential.
But Valdez's rookie season also exposed some concerning weaknesses. Outside of July, he hit just .121 with a 40% strikeout rate. His overall strikeout rate finished at 37.6%, illustrating just how much swing-and-miss remains in his game.
His platoon splits are particularly relevant to the Baddoo decision. Valdez posted a 1.011 OPS against left-handed pitching in 2026, compared to a .761 OPS against right-handers. He also struck out in nearly 40% of his plate appearances against righties.
Baddoo, meanwhile, is a left-handed hitter who has historically enjoyed more success against right-handed pitching. That creates at least the possibility of a complementary arrangement, allowing Pittsburgh to give Valdez more favorable matchups while maintaining another outfield option against right-handed starters.
There's also the injury consideration. Valdez's promising rookie season ended prematurely because of a hamstring strain, although he reported being fully healthy in October. Between the injury, extreme strikeout tendencies and inconsistent production, the Pirates have legitimate reasons to avoid entering 2027 without alternatives.
That doesn't necessarily mean Baddoo is being retained specifically to challenge Valdez for playing time. Pittsburgh has other outfield questions to address, and Baddoo could simply be competing for a bench role alongside the club's existing depth options. Still, his contract suggests the Pirates aren't ready to dismiss the possibility that he could contribute at the major league level.
Valdez is still just 22 years old, and his upside dramatically exceeds that of Baddoo, who hasn't established himself as a consistently productive major league hitter since his promising 2021 rookie season with Detroit. The Pirates should absolutely have contingency plans if Valdez struggles or gets hurt, but they also need to give one of their most promising young power hitters the opportunities necessary to become a complete offensive player.
If Baddoo earns a roster spot as a complementary outfielder, that's perfectly reasonable. If Pittsburgh starts sacrificing Valdez's development to accommodate another veteran reclamation project, that's a different conversation entirely.
Of course, Baddoo's contract doesn't guarantee he'll make the Opening Day roster. The Pirates could still expose him to waivers during spring training, and the split agreement provides some financial flexibility if he clears. But after claiming him earlier this month, Pittsburgh has now made a second deliberate decision to keep him in the organization.
That doesn't prove anything about Valdez's projected role. It does, however, suggest that Ben Cherington sees enough uncertainty in his current outfield picture to justify preserving another potential major league option.
