The Chicago White Sox just made a rather expensive statement about the state of the starting pitching market, and the Pittsburgh Pirates should be paying close attention.
FanSided MLB insider Robert Murray was first to report that Chicago agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with right-hander Dustin May, a staggering commitment for a pitcher who finished the 2026 season with a 4.70 ERA across 145 2/3 innings between the St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers.
May is just 29 years old and still possesses considerable upside, but his injury history and inconsistent results hardly make him a sure thing. Nevertheless, the White Sox apparently decided he was worth $17.5 million annually.
For Pirates general manager Ben Cherington, that deal could significantly change the conversation surrounding one of Pittsburgh's most complicated offseason decisions: what to do with Mitch Keller.
Dustin May is heading to the Southside, per @ByRobertMurray and @JonHeyman pic.twitter.com/F4H0vUV6l9
— FOX Sports: MLB (@MLBONFOX) November 17, 2026
Dustin May's White Sox contract puts Mitch Keller's remaining salary in a different light
Keller's contract has increasingly looked like a liability for the Pirates. The 30-year-old is coming off a disastrous 2026 campaign in which he posted a 5.29 ERA over 22 starts before a severe teres major injury ended his season in August.
Making matters worse, Keller's salary is only going up. He's owed approximately $18.4 million in 2027 and $20.4 million in 2028, leaving Pittsburgh responsible for nearly $38.8 million over the final two years of his extension. For a team with Pittsburgh's historically limited payroll, that's a substantial commitment to a pitcher coming off arguably his worst season.
But consider what the White Sox just paid May. Keller's remaining contract carries an average annual salary of approximately $19.4 million, less than $2 million more than May's new deal. And while May has the advantage of youth and a healthier 2026 workload, Keller has a much longer track record of handling a full season's worth of starts.
From 2022 through 2025, Keller averaged roughly 31 starts per season and posted a 4.15 ERA. His 2026 struggles were alarming, but the Pirates have reason to believe his injury contributed to his decline. Suddenly, his contract doesn't look quite as outrageous relative to the available alternatives.
That doesn't necessarily mean other clubs will line up to acquire him. His injury concerns are legitimate, and the Pirates might still have to absorb salary to facilitate a trade. But if teams are willing to guarantee more than $50 million to a pitcher with May's question marks, Keller's remaining commitment might not be the obstacle it once appeared to be.
Pirates must decide whether trading Mitch Keller creates more problems than it solves
There's another side to this equation, however, and it's one Cherington cannot afford to overlook. An increasingly expensive starting pitching market might make Keller easier to trade, but it also makes replacing him considerably more difficult.
The Pirates have an enviable collection of young arms in Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler and Braxton Ashcraft. Still, expecting that group to carry an entire rotation without reliable veteran depth would be a considerable gamble.
Pittsburgh could clear nearly $39 million in future commitments by trading Keller, but finding an established replacement might consume much of those savings. And with the Pirates already facing significant offensive needs, particularly following Brandon Lowe's departure into free agency, committing substantial additional resources to another mid-rotation starter hardly seems ideal.
Cherington has maintained that the organization believes Keller can rebound in 2027. The White Sox's investment in May offers another reason to consider keeping him rather than selling low.
Ultimately, one contract doesn't establish the price of every available starter. But Chicago's willingness to pay $17.5 million annually for upside rather than certainty should force Pittsburgh to reevaluate Keller's market value.
The Pirates shouldn't trade Keller simply because he's expensive. They should trade him only if doing so makes the roster better. And the White Sox may have just made that distinction considerably more important.
