Brandon Lowe's openness to a Pirates extension means nothing given team's stingy history

Brandon Lowe has met or exceeded every expectation placed on him after the Pittsburgh Pirates traded for him back in December 2025. Lowe's best season was previously with the Rays back in 2021, where he posted an .863 OPS with 39 homers and accumulated 4.6 rWAR. While he will have to really pick up the pace to catch up with that home run total, Lowe has still cracked 32 homers through 143 games while also being one of the best defensive second basemen in all of baseball.

Given how good Lowe has been, discussion has understandably turned to a potential extension with the Pirates. No one has argued that Lowe wouldn't be worth the investment, but there has been a fair bit of skepticism that the two sides could agree on extension terms given the Pirates' payroll "limits" as well as how much Lowe's price tag has gone up in 2026.

However, a ray of hope appeared in a report from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette's Colin Beazley. In that report, Lowe was quoted as not only being open to a potential contract extension with the Pirates, but also as firmly believing in the franchise’s direction and future. That said, the devil may be in the details.

Brandon Lowe may be willing to sign an extension with the Pirates, but that doesn't mean Pittsburgh will step up

The one thing everyone probably agrees with is that the days of a cheaper extension for Lowe are likely gone. Pittsburgh may have had a chance for a bargain extension immediately after the trade, but there is no chance that Lowe would do so now after a 5+ WAR season, nor should he.

And therein is the problem. Optimism around the Pirates is high right now despite falling short in the playoff race, but the fact remains that Bob Nutting is still the owner and Ben Cherington is still the GM. That dynamic duo has not combined to put together the type of deal that is going to be required to keep Lowe around. The Konnor Griffin extension is in the ballpark, but Griffin and Lowe are at very different stages of their careers and are very different players.

That said, fans shouldn't lose all hope. There is no reason to believe that Lowe wasn't being sincere in his desire to stick around when he said, “I think this team’s got a very bright future and a lot of good players, and there’s a lot of good baseball that’s going to be played in this park for a long time. [If] they want to talk, I’m all ears.” Nutting could also be convinced to give Lowe a real extension offer if he was convinced that a significant payroll floor was inevitable as a result of the upcoming CBA talks and lockout.

In short, Lowe's comments are a step in the right direction. It takes two to tango, and it is nice to hear that he is willing to pick up the phone if the Pirates come calling with a real offer. Unfortunately, until we see otherwise, skepticism that the Pirates will actually capitalize on the opportunity right in front of them with Lowe is pretty warranted.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow