Skip to main content

Brandon Lowe's latest free agency development puts Pirates in an increasingly impossible position

The competition is growing. Pittsburgh is running out of leverage.
ByEmma Lingan
Boston Red Sox v. Pittsburgh Pirates
Boston Red Sox v. Pittsburgh Pirates | Christopher Denver/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Pirates keep saying they want Brandon Lowe back. Unfortunately for Ben Cherington, so does seemingly everyone else.

What was already shaping up to be a difficult free agency battle has become considerably more complicated. According to MLB Network's Jon Paul Morosi, more than half a dozen teams are expressing interest in Lowe, including the New York Yankees, Toronto Blue Jays and, perhaps most ironically, his former team, the Tampa Bay Rays.

For the Pirates, it's another reminder that their hopes of retaining their most productive offensive player are becoming increasingly difficult to reconcile with the realities of the free-agent market.

Lowe's decision to decline Pittsburgh's $23.15 million qualifying offer earlier this week was hardly surprising. After hitting .260 with 35 home runs and 96 RBI, winning his first Silver Slugger Award and dramatically improving his defense at second base, the 32-year-old has positioned himself for a lucrative multiyear contract.

And now, with the list of potential suitors growing, the Pirates are running out of reasons to believe patience will work in their favor.

Rays' interest adds another frustrating wrinkle to Brandon Lowe's free agency

The Pirates acquired Lowe last offseason in a three-team trade that also brought Mason Montgomery and Jake Mangum to Pittsburgh. Lowe proceeded to enjoy one of the best seasons of his career, helping transform an offense that had been among baseball's worst. Now, after getting precisely the production they desperately needed, the Pirates could watch him return to the organization that traded him away.

The Rays have their own financial considerations, and reported interest doesn't guarantee a competitive offer. But the broader implications should concern Pittsburgh. The Yankees and Blue Jays already represented formidable competition. Adding Tampa Bay and several other interested clubs only increases the likelihood that Lowe will have multiple legitimate offers to consider.

During the GM meetings last week, Cherington acknowledged that the Pirates remained in contact with Lowe and his representatives. He also revealed that Pittsburgh hadn't pursued extension negotiations during the season, believing the timing was inappropriate amid a playoff push.

That's understandable to a point. But it also meant the Pirates entered the offseason without any contractual advantage beyond Lowe's familiarity with the organization.

The Pirates need offensive upgrades regardless of whether Lowe returns. Losing their leading home run hitter would only increase that urgency, particularly for a lineup that struggled to sustain its first-half production down the stretch. And with a potential MLB lockout beginning December 2, the window to make meaningful progress before negotiations potentially freeze is narrowing.

Cherington doesn't necessarily have to resolve Lowe's free agency before then. He does, however, need a plan that doesn't depend entirely on waiting for Lowe to make up his mind.

The Pirates can establish what they're willing to pay, make a serious offer and simultaneously pursue alternatives. They can't afford to let other opportunities disappear while hoping the market eventually becomes more favorable.

The Pirates spent last offseason identifying a player capable of transforming their offense. They succeeded spectacularly. Now they're facing the possibility of losing him after just one season, potentially even to the team that traded him away.

Cherington doesn't have to win a bidding war at any cost. But with every new interested team, the cost of waiting becomes harder to justify.

Add us as a preferred source on Google