The Pittsburgh Pirates aren't the only team looking for a long-term solution at third base. Unfortunately, another club just demonstrated exactly how expensive finding one can be.
The Seattle Mariners made one of the biggest moves of the offseason Wednesday, acquiring Gold Glove third baseman Maikel Garcia from the Kansas City Royals in a six-player blockbuster. In exchange, Seattle surrendered three pitchers with major league experience: Bryce Miller, Logan Evans and José A. Ferrer. The Mariners also received right-hander James McArthur and pitching prospect L.P. Langevin.
For a Pirates team still searching for answers at third base, the trade should serve as a warning. Meaningful upgrades don't come cheap, and Pittsburgh might not have nearly as much expendable pitching as general manager Ben Cherington would like to believe.
Garcia, 26, represents exactly the kind of player the Pirates should be targeting. He's a proven defender with offensive upside who is under contract through 2030, with a club option for 2031. He won a Gold Glove and earned an All-Star selection in 2025, hitting .286/.351/.449 with 16 home runs and 23 stolen bases. Injuries limited him to 82 games and a .715 OPS in 2026, but his long-term value remains substantial. Seattle was willing to pay accordingly.
Mariners' Maikel Garcia trade exposes difficult reality for Pirates' third-base plans
The Pirates have spent years building what should be one of their greatest organizational strengths: pitching depth. Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler and Braxton Ashcraft give Pittsburgh an exciting collection of young arms, while Mitch Keller and Carmen Mlodzinski provide additional options.
Skenes should be untouchable. Jones and Chandler are essential pieces of Pittsburgh's long-term rotation plans, and Ashcraft's emergence makes him difficult to part with. Keller is coming off an injury-shortened, disappointing season, complicating his trade value despite his substantial salary.
Mlodzinski could be an interesting trade candidate, particularly with his future role still unsettled. But would a package built around him be enough to acquire an established, controllable third baseman? Seattle's willingness to part with Miller, Evans and Ferrer suggests that the answer might be no.
Granted, the Mariners weren't surrendering three established aces. Miller posted a 4.17 ERA in 2026, Evans missed the entire season recovering from elbow surgery, and Ferrer finished with a 4.18 ERA. Still, all three have major league experience, and Miller offers legitimate rotation upside.
More importantly, Seattle could afford to make that sacrifice because of its considerable starting pitching depth. Pittsburgh isn't necessarily in the same position. In fact, the Pirates are reportedly looking to add pitching themselves, particularly left-handed arms. Trading away multiple controllable pitchers to address third base could simply create another expensive problem elsewhere on the roster.
Ben Cherington can't afford another offseason without a real third-base solution
The urgency surrounding Pittsburgh's third-base search isn't difficult to understand. Nick Gonzales hit .303 in 2026, but his transition to third base was a defensive disaster, resulting in minus-15 defensive runs saved. Jared Triolo offers a much stronger glove, but his limited offensive production makes him a questionable everyday solution for a team still trying to build a consistently competitive lineup.
And with Brandon Lowe's future in Pittsburgh uncertain, the Pirates could find themselves needing to replace significant offensive production at multiple infield positions.
The Mariners identified a glaring weakness, targeted a player who could solve it for years and accepted the cost of acquiring him. They didn't allow the desire to preserve every piece of their pitching depth to prevent a meaningful upgrade.
"We didn't think he would be available, and lo and behold."@Mariners POBO Jerry Dipoto gives his perspective on Seattle's trade for Maikel Garcia and what he provides.
— MLB Network (@MLBNetwork) November 19, 2026
MLB Network + @SageUSAmerica https://t.co/p9GPcDDT8y pic.twitter.com/NEIAvEBf6L
Cherington doesn't necessarily need to replicate that strategy. In fact, sacrificing multiple young pitchers for one infielder could be reckless given Pittsburgh's current circumstances. But the Pirates can't continue treating their pitching depth as both an untouchable foundation and a convenient source of trade assets.
If Pittsburgh wants to acquire a legitimate everyday third baseman, Cherington might have to part with someone he'd rather keep. Alternatively, ownership could authorize enough spending to pursue an established offensive upgrade without weakening the pitching staff.
Neither option is especially comfortable. The alternative, though, is another offseason of bargain hunting, internal experiments and hoping someone unexpectedly develops into the answer.
Seattle just demonstrated what a team is willing to sacrifice for long-term certainty at third base. The Pirates now have to decide whether they're prepared to make a similarly difficult commitment — or settle for considerably less.
