Skip to main content

Pirates’ Rule 5 decisions expose painful reversal for Ben Cherington’s rebuild

From $7.2 million cornerstone to Rule 5 afterthought.
ByEmma Lingan
Detroit Tigers v. Pittsburgh Pirates
Detroit Tigers v. Pittsburgh Pirates | Julio Aguilar/GettyImages

Four years ago, Termarr Johnson was supposed to be one of the crown jewels of the Pittsburgh Pirates' rebuild. Axiel Plaz was a relatively unheralded international signing who barely registered on the organization's prospect radar.

On Tuesday, the Pirates protected Plaz from the Rule 5 Draft while leaving Johnson exposed. It's a remarkable reversal of fortunes for two players who entered Pittsburgh's farm system in 2022 under dramatically different circumstances. And while the decisions make sense when evaluating where each player stands today, they also offer a rather uncomfortable reminder of how far some of Ben Cherington's biggest rebuilding investments have fallen.

Johnson was the fourth overall pick in the 2022 MLB Draft, signing for a whopping $7.219 million. Considered one of the best pure high school hitters in years, he arrived with enormous expectations and was supposed to develop into a cornerstone of Pittsburgh's next competitive roster.

Plaz, meanwhile, signed out of Venezuela for just $350,000 in January 2022. His signing bonus was less than five percent of Johnson's, and his path to the major leagues was considerably less certain.

Four years later, it's Plaz who has earned a coveted spot on the Pirates' 40-man roster.

Pirates' Axiel Plaz decision highlights how far Termarr Johnson's stock has fallen

To be clear, Plaz's emergence is a success story for Pittsburgh's scouting and player development departments. The 21-year-old catcher enjoyed a breakout 2026 season at High-A Greensboro, slashing .305/.389/.513 with 18 home runs and 74 RBI. He also reduced his strikeout rate to a career-low 17.2%, demonstrating that his offensive improvement wasn't simply the product of selling out for more power.

Now ranked as Pittsburgh's No. 7 prospect by MLB Pipeline, Plaz has developed into a legitimate organizational asset despite never playing above High-A.

Johnson's trajectory has been considerably less encouraging. After showing signs of progress at Double-A Altoona in 2025, the former first-rounder struggled through a disastrous 2026 campaign at Triple-A Indianapolis. He hit just .199/.336/.319 with eight home runs and 101 strikeouts in 96 games before suffering season-ending ACL and LCL tears in his left knee.

The injury provides important context for Pittsburgh's decision. Johnson is unlikely to be ready to contribute at the major league level early in 2027, making him a difficult Rule 5 selection for another organization to carry. Keeping him off the 40-man roster would also allow the Pirates to continue communicating with him throughout his rehabilitation during a potential MLB lockout.

In other words, leaving Johnson unprotected isn't necessarily a mistake. It's the fact that leaving him unprotected has become such a defensible decision that's concerning.

Four years after investing more than $7 million in a player widely regarded as an elite hitting prospect, the Pirates apparently have little reason to believe another organization will be eager to sacrifice a major league roster spot to acquire him. And although Plaz's inclusion on the roster is encouraging, it doesn't erase the disappointment surrounding Johnson.

Cherington's rebuild was supposed to be built on accumulating and developing premium young talent, particularly through the draft. Pittsburgh invested significant resources in Johnson because of his potential to become an impact major league hitter, not because he might eventually develop into useful organizational depth.

At 22 years old, Johnson still has time to reverse his fortunes. His career is far from over, and the Pirates could ultimately benefit from keeping him unprotected while he recovers. But the contrast with Plaz is staggering.

The prospect who arrived with a $350,000 signing bonus is now considered valuable enough to protect from other organizations. The player Pittsburgh spent more than $7.2 million to acquire is being left available. It's a testament to Plaz's development, but also a painful illustration of just how dramatically Cherington's prospect hierarchy has changed.

The Pirates deserve credit for finding value where few expected it. They also have to answer for why one of their most expensive rebuilding investments has yet to deliver on its promise.

Add us as a preferred source on Google